A Multitude of Challenges: Understanding Low Agricultural Productivity in India
Low agricultural productivity in India stems from a complex interplay of general, institutional, technical, and marketing challenges. These issues are interconnected and often exacerbate each other, hindering the sector’s ability to reach its full potential.
General Factors:
-
Population Pressure and Uneconomic Holdings: India’s burgeoning population and the limited availability of non-agricultural employment opportunities have resulted in increased pressure on agricultural land. This pressure has led to a continuous increase in the number of agricultural laborers and a decrease in the average size of landholdings. The predominance of small and fragmented landholdings, particularly those below two hectares, presents significant challenges for efficient agricultural production. These small farms often lack the resources to invest in modern technologies and practices. Their small marketable surplus also makes them vulnerable to exploitation by intermediaries.
-
Land Degradation: Intensive cultivation practices, coupled with the indiscriminate use of chemical fertilizers, have taken a toll on soil health. The sources highlight the alarming extent of soil degradation in India, estimating agricultural output losses of $1.9 billion annually due to this issue. The decline in soil fertility not only reduces current productivity but also jeopardizes the sustainability of future agricultural production.
Institutional Constraints:
-
Legacy of Exploitative Land Tenure Systems: Historically, the zamindari system, with its absentee landlords and exploitative rent practices, discouraged investment in land improvement and hindered productivity growth. While land reforms aimed at abolishing intermediaries and redistributing land have been implemented, their effectiveness in empowering tenant farmers and improving their economic well-being has been limited.
-
Inadequate Access to Credit and Market Infrastructure: Small and marginal farmers often struggle to access formal credit due to their lack of collateral and limited financial literacy. This forces them to depend on informal sources like moneylenders, who charge high-interest rates, trapping them in a cycle of debt. Furthermore, the lack of proper warehousing and storage facilities in rural areas leads to significant post-harvest losses, further reducing farmers’ incomes. The absence of robust market infrastructure, including efficient transportation networks and market information systems, also limits farmers’ ability to get fair prices for their produce.
Technical Limitations:
-
Outdated Farming Practices: A significant proportion of Indian farmers continue to rely on traditional farming methods characterized by low input use and limited adoption of modern technologies. The low uptake of high-yielding varieties of seeds, improved irrigation techniques, and farm mechanization contributes to low productivity. The sources emphasize that while the Green Revolution introduced high-yielding varieties and modern practices, its benefits were largely confined to certain regions and crops, leaving a substantial portion of the agricultural sector untouched.
-
Inadequate Irrigation Infrastructure: Despite progress in irrigation development, a large portion of the cultivated area remains dependent on rainfall, making Indian agriculture vulnerable to the vagaries of the monsoon. The sources highlight that the uneven distribution of irrigation facilities, aging infrastructure, and inefficient water management practices further exacerbate the problem. They also point out that the expansion of irrigated area and the increase in per hectare yields on irrigated land were major contributors to agricultural growth between the early 1970s and early 1990s, underscoring the importance of addressing irrigation challenges.
Marketing Inefficiencies:
- High Marketing Costs and Exploitation of Small Farmers: The agricultural marketing system in India is characterized by high costs and the presence of multiple intermediaries. Small farmers, with their limited marketable surplus and weak bargaining power, are particularly vulnerable to exploitation by these intermediaries. The lack of grading and standardization practices further reduces the prices they receive for their produce. The sources highlight that the benefits of government-announced minimum support prices often fail to reach small farmers due to their immediate cash needs and the lack of access to regulated markets.
These multifaceted challenges underscore the urgent need for comprehensive policy interventions to address the issue of low productivity in Indian agriculture. The sources suggest various measures, including promoting sustainable farming practices, investing in rural infrastructure, strengthening farmer institutions, improving access to credit and markets, and facilitating the transfer of technology to enhance productivity and ensure the long-term sustainability of the sector.